Celery, cucumbers, and grapefruit are often cited as foods with negative caloric content. We analyzed the origin of this myth, what science says about it, and how low-calorie items truly affect body mass.
The core of the concept
Some people assume that the body expends more vitality to process certain vegetables and fruits than it gains from them. In that scenario, they might aid weight loss on their own.
This notion stems from a genuine mechanism—the thermic effect of food. After eating, the body indeed consumes some energy. It spends this energy on chewing, stomach and intestinal function, plus nutrient processing.
On average, the thermic effect accounts for:
up to 30% of energy from proteins;
up to 10% from carbohydrates;
up to 5% from fats.
A portion of the calories remains and is used for organ function, movement, and other requirements. The body cannot completely burn all the food’s energy during its processing. Therefore, from a physiological angle, meals with negative caloric value are impossible. They provide minimal energy, but they still provide some.
Eight ways to overcome cravings for unhealthy food named
What the research reveals
One of the most recognized experiments was conducted on bearded dragons. These omnivorous lizards have digestive principles largely mirroring those of mammals. The animals were fed raw celery, and researchers measured the energy they gained, what they lost via feces and urine, and what was spent on digestion. It turned out the net energy balance remained positive: the lizards absorbed about a quarter of the calories present in the celery.
A prolonged randomized study on humans compared a diet purported to have negative calories with a standard low-calorie eating plan. Participants in both groups received the same amount of daily energy. After several months, no difference was found in weight reduction or body mass index between the groups. The authors concluded that the very notion of negative caloric content lacks practical relevance.
Foods with “negative caloric value”
Such lists typically include produce with high water and fiber content and low calories per serving.
Most frequently mentioned are:
celery, cucumbers, zucchini, leafy greens;
broccoli, cauliflower, tomatoes;
apples, grapefruits, berries, watermelons;
water without additives.
Fiber slows down the passage of food through the digestive tract and helps sustain satiety longer. Water enhances this feeling. Consequently, it becomes easier for a person to reduce their total daily caloric intake.
A doctor reminded who should absolutely avoid eating red caviar
How to use these items for weight management
Low-calorie vegetables and fruits work best not in isolation, but as part of a balanced diet. Their role is not to burn calories, but to assist in eating less without constant hunger pangs.
A vegetable salad before lunch or dinner helps achieve fullness sooner and lessens the risk of overeating. Vegetable side dishes and soups made with vegetable broth function on the same principle.
© Tijana Simic/iStock.com
It is crucial to pair them with sources of protein and fats. Protein maintains satiety and muscle mass, while fats slow stomach emptying and make meals tastier.
One should not base an entire eating plan solely on low-calorie items. Such an approach quickly leads to deficiencies in energy, protein, and micronutrients. This raises the chance of setbacks and worsens general well-being.
In practice, substitution yields the best outcome. If vegetables, fruits, and dishes based on them gradually supplant more caloric snacks and sides, daily caloric intake drops without rigid prohibitions or constant monitoring.
Doctors named 5 grains that help people slim down
The crucial point: foods with negative caloric value do not exist
The concept of negative calories arose due to the thermic effect of food, but this mechanism never entirely offsets a food’s caloric value. Scientific evidence confirms this. High-water and high-fiber produce aids weight loss for a different reason. They provide good satiety and allow for a reduction in overall calorie consumption without severe restrictions. The optimal result comes not from seeking magic foods, but from sensible substitutions within the diet and balanced nourishment.
About the Author
