For the first time, physicists have observed light “voids” that are capable of propagating faster than light itself. Labeled as phase singularities or optical vortices, predictions dating back to the 1970s suggested that, much like whirlpools in a river can outpace the surrounding water flow, vortices within a light wave could overtake the light carrying them. These findings have been detailed in the journal Nature.
This observation does not violate the theory of relativity, which posits that nothing can exceed the speed of light. The reason is that these vortices do not transport any mass, energy, or information; their movement is rooted in the evolving geometry of the wave pattern rather than actual physical travel through space.
Capturing this phenomenon in action proved challenging, however, as it occurs across extremely minute scales of both distance and time. This successful observation represents a major achievement in electron microscopy.
“Our discovery illuminates universal principles governing nature, applicable across all wave types—from sound waves and fluid dynamics to intricate systems such as superconductors,” states Ido Kaminer from the Technion – Israel Institute of Technology. “This breakthrough offers us a powerful technological means: the ability to map the dynamics of subtle nanoscale phenomena within materials, made visible through a novel technique (electron interferometry) that enhances image sharpness.”
Although light appears uniform to our eyes, numerous processes occur within it that are difficult for us to discern. Light is susceptible to disturbances akin to those seen in other systems dominated by flow dynamics, including the specific type of phase singularity dubbed an optical vortex.
Light exhibits dual wave-particle behavior; an optical vortex forms when the wave twists as it propagates, resembling a corkscrew. At the very core of this twist, the light cancels itself out (interferes destructively), creating a point of zero intensity—a kind of dark “hole” within the light field.
Mathematically, it is understood that two singularities within the same frame of reference will attract one another, gaining speed as they converge and potentially reaching velocities that appear to surpass the speed of light in a vacuum.
The researchers explain in their paper, “As singularities with opposite charges approach each other, their trajectories within spacetime must form a continuous curve at the point of annihilation, causing them to accelerate to theoretically unbounded speeds just prior to annihilation.”
This behavior has been documented in other physical systems, but examining how this scenario unfolds within a light field presents unique complexities. While extensive laboratory work has explored this theoretically, direct observation of optical vortices was constrained by technology’s inability to keep pace with the speed at which the vortices formed, moved, and collided.
To overcome these limitations, Kaminer and his team recorded the behavior of optical vortices within a two-dimensional material known as hexagonal boron nitride.
This material supports unusual light waves called phonon polaritons—a hybrid of light and atomic vibrations—which travel at a significantly reduced speed compared to light alone and can be tightly confined. This confinement generates intricate interference patterns filled with numerous vortices, enabling researchers to track their movements in detail.
The second critical hurdle was capturing these dynamics in real-time. The team employed a specialized, high-speed electron microscope possessing unprecedented spatial and temporal resolution, capable of registering events unfolding as quickly as quadrillionths of a second (femtoseconds).
They repeated the experiment numerous times, each recording slightly offset in timing from the previous run. By compiling hundreds of these resultant images, the researchers constructed a stop-motion sequence of the vortices rapidly converging and annihilating each other, briefly achieving superluminal speeds during this process.
The experiment was conducted in a two-dimensional setting. The researchers indicate that the next phase involves extending their methodology to higher dimensions to observe more complex behaviors. They also note that the microscopy techniques they developed could help circumvent certain existing constraints in electron microscopy.
“We anticipate that these innovative microscopic methods will allow for the investigation of hidden processes across physics, chemistry, and biology,” Kaminer concludes, “revealing for the first time how nature operates in its fastest and most elusive moments.”
About the Author
