A meeting with a black hole (BH) represents one of the most terrifying imaginable scenarios. However, the finale of such an incident will not necessarily be fatal—the outcome depends entirely on the mass of this “devourer.” We will explore the most dramatic variant: a collision with a solitary, wandering stellar-mass BH, approximately ten times the mass of the Sun. Every Black Hole Carries Its Own Catastrophe Not all black holes possess the same destructive power. They can be classified by mass and size into three main categories. These parameters determine what will happen to a planet upon close approach. Supermassive. These colossal objects, whose mass is measured in millions or billions of solar masses, reside at the centers of galaxies. If such a BH approached our Solar System, it would swallow it whole. Paradoxically, due to their gigantic size, the tidal forces at their boundary are relatively small. A planet could cross the event horizon without being immediately torn apart. Destruction would occur already inside. Microscopic. At the opposite end of the spectrum are hypothetical primordial BHs, possibly formed after the Big Bang. If an object the size of an asteroid passed through the Earth, it would likely leave only a tiny channel of disturbed rock. Nobody would even notice this mini-catastrophe. Stellar-Mass. BHs with masses around 10 solar masses are the most destructive to planets. They possess significant mass but have a small event horizon. This creates an extremely steep gravitational gradient. The tidal forces of such a hole would tear an object to shreds long before it reached the event horizon. Let’s analyze the situation where the Earth collides with a BH ten times the mass of the Sun. What will happen to our planet? One Year Before the Approach Long before the BH could be seen through telescopes, its presence would be felt by Earth’s inhabitants. Here are the phenomena that would be observed: The Onset of a Comet Storm The farthest and most loosely bound region of the Solar System—the Oort Cloud—will be the first to react to the intrusion. This is a gigantic sphere containing trillions of icy bodies. The approach of an object with a mass of 10 Suns will cause a gravitational perturbation, sweeping these bodies from their distant orbits. Billions of comets will rush toward the inner Solar System. The first tangible disaster on Earth will be a continuous barrage of meteoroids and comets. These bombardments will begin even before astronomers can detect the threat itself. Planetary Dance and First Detection As the BH approaches, its gravitational influence will begin to alter the trajectories of the outer giant planets: Neptune, Uranus, and Saturn. An object of this mass could even eject a number of planets from the Solar System. Since “rogue” BHs are invisible (unless they are accreting matter), the only way to detect them is through the phenomenon of gravitational lensing. The mass of the BH warps the light of stars located behind it. Astronomers will notice stars in the background of the unseen object temporarily distorting, doubling, and brightening. However, if the BH is moving fast, this “moment of observation” might be very brief. As a result, scientists will learn about the approaching BH only a few months before the catastrophe. One Month Before Impact At this stage, the BH’s gravity begins to dominate the inner Solar System. Farewell to the Moon The Moon will be the first victim. The BH will rapidly weaken Earth’s gravitational bond with its natural satellite and rip it from its orbit around Earth. The Moon could either be ejected into interstellar space or captured into an orbit around the BH itself. A third scenario exists—the Moon colliding with Earth. In any case, the planet will lose the stabilizer for its axial tilt. How the Earth Will Change After Losing the Moon Megatides and Planetary Transformation Tides arise from the difference in gravitational pull between the near and far sides of a planet. A stellar-mass BH creates a much sharper gradient than the Moon. Under its influence, tides on Earth will become unpredictable. Ocean waters, acted upon by the black hole’s gravity, will rise hundreds of meters, generating monstrous megatsunamis. Simultaneously, the gravitational “tug-of-war” between the Sun and the BH will transform Earth’s nearly circular orbit into a highly elongated ellipse. This will completely destroy the climate. The Milankovitch cycles, which usually take millennia, will shrink to mere months. The planet will begin to swing between two extremes: approaching the Sun, it will experience catastrophic overheating with the evaporation of oceans, and moving away into distant space, it will plunge into icy cold. These rapid thermal “swings,” combined with megatsunamis, will trigger the rapid extinction of life on the planet. One Hour Before Impact In the final stage, the main destroyer is not gravity itself, but its gradient—the tidal forces. The Earth’s surface facing the BH experiences immeasurably stronger attraction than the opposite side. Tidal Disruption When the planet crosses its Roche Limit—the point where the BH’s tidal forces overcome the Earth’s own gravity—its destruction becomes inevitable. For a stellar-mass BH, this zone lies far outside the event horizon. The final result is spaghettification. This term describes the process where a body is stretched toward the BH and compressed horizontally. The destruction occurs in stages, layer by layer: Atmosphere. As the least bound element, it is stripped off first. Gas rushes into space toward the black hole. Oceans. Following the gas is the hydrosphere. Water detaches from the surface and flows toward the BH in gigantic “cosmic streams.” Earth’s Crust. After the fluids and gases are stripped away, the solid ground of the Earth reaches its breaking point. The crust cracks under tidal stress, like an eggshell. Magma from the mantle and core erupts directly into space. “Noodles.” All remaining substance—molten rock, the metallic core, and plasma—undergoes complete stretching. The planet transforms into a long, thin, incandescent jet of plasma and rock. The Final Glow Earth’s fate is more of a transformation than complete annihilation. The stream of the “former Earth” does not fall directly into the BH. Since the planet had orbital velocity and its own rotation, this material conserves angular momentum. This causes the matter to swirl around the BH. The stream quickly flattens and forms a massive, chaotic accretion disk. In this disk, matter in different orbits moves at different speeds. This generates enormous internal friction, converting kinetic energy into thermal energy. The temperature of the disk soars to millions of degrees Celsius. The highly heated plasma begins to emit intense radiation in the X-ray and gamma-ray ranges. This phenomenon is known as a tidal disruption event. For a short time, this flare will shine brighter than the Sun in the X-ray spectrum. The black hole, previously invisible, “by eating” the mass of the Earth, becomes an incredibly powerful source of radiation. In its final moments, the Earth’s matter becomes an energy source, sterilizing the rest of the Solar System with a powerful burst of hard radiation. Conclusion The described scenario of a direct collision is better suited for thought experiments than for predicting the real outcome. The probability that a wandering BH will invade the Solar System and head directly for Earth is negligibly small. Space is immensely vast, and the distances between bodies are colossal. According to some estimates, the chance of our planet being swallowed by a wandering BH is lower than the probability of winning the lottery ten times in a row—a ratio of about one in a trillion. Thus, this apocalypse remains in the realm of science fiction. A more probable, although still highly unlikely, scenario is the BH flying past the Solar System rather than a direct collision. BHs are not “cosmic vacuum cleaners”; their main effect is gravity. If a BH passed at a great distance, for instance, beyond Neptune’s orbit, its primary influence would be felt by the Oort Cloud, triggering a massive comet shower that would rain down on the inner system. The stable orbits of the distant gas giants would also be disrupted. Most likely, the black hole would simply flash by, having significantly “shaken up” the Solar System, but not necessarily destroying the Earth.
About the Author
