Modern research disproves the simplistic approach to weight loss that relies solely on the balance between calories consumed and burned. It turns out that what matters most is not just the quantity, but the quality and source of calories, as well as individual body characteristics.
Photo: collage by RuNews24.ru
For a long time, dietitians and fitness gurus insisted that losing weight only requires burning more calories than you take in. However, recent scientific evidence shows that this formula only works in part. Today, scientists agree that the source of energy is decisive, not just the dry numbers on a package. The body absorbs the same 100 kilocalories in completely different ways depending on many factors, and blindly following a calculator may not only fail to help but could also mislead.
First of all, the actual energy value of foods often differs from what is listed on labels. Manufacturers round off the figures, and the margin of error can be as high as 20%. But this is just the tip of the iceberg. Absorption is influenced by everything: the degree of cooking, food texture, fruit ripeness, genetic traits, and even the state of gut microbiota. For instance, cooked vegetables release energy more easily than raw ones, while almonds ground into flour are absorbed much more fully than whole nuts. Unripe bananas contain fewer available calories than their overripe counterparts.
Moreover, a meal with the same calorie count can trigger completely opposite metabolic reactions in the body. Fast carbohydrates from white bread or sweets cause a sharp spike in blood sugar, prompting a strong release of insulin, which signals the need to store fat. Hunger returns very quickly as a result. In contrast, fiber and resistant starches from grains, legumes, and nuts digest slowly, providing long-lasting fullness, and some of their calories are not even absorbed into the bloodstream. Thus, 200 calories from a handful of nuts bring more benefits to the body than 100 calories from sugary soda.
Researchers pay special attention to ultra-processed foods. Their consumption lowers the baseline level of energy expenditure at rest: the body starts burning fewer calories and more actively stores fat. Even factors like sleep quality change the picture: after a sleepless night, metabolism shifts, and the calories consumed are used differently. Two people eating the same meal can experience completely different weight gain due to differences in hormonal balance and physical activity. Experts advise viewing calorie counting only as a rough guideline for portion control, not as an absolute rule. It is far more effective to focus on diet quality: add more vegetables, legumes, and whole foods, and reduce the share of sugar and processed items.
About the Author
