Japanese researchers have determined that the weight gain associated with bread and rice consumption is not due to their caloric content but rather their impact on metabolism. An experiment demonstrated that a diet high in carbohydrates reduces energy expenditure and initiates fat accumulation.
Bread and rice may lead to obesity even without overeating, according to scientists from Osaka Metropolitan University. Their experiment revealed that carbohydrate-rich foods alter metabolic function, decreasing the body’s energy output and triggering the storage of fat.
The study, led by Professor Shigenobu Matsumura and published in Molecular Nutrition & Food Research, investigated how different carbohydrate sources affect metabolic processes. Mice were divided into groups consuming various diets: standard chow, chow supplemented with bread, or chow with wheat and rice flour, alongside a high-fat diet that also included carbohydrates.
Throughout the trial, researchers monitored body weight, levels of adipose tissue, blood parameters, and gene activity within the liver. Indirect calorimetry, which involved analyzing the composition of exhaled gases, was used to quantify energy expenditure.
The findings indicated that mice fed carbohydrates preferentially consumed them, almost entirely foregoing the standard diet. Despite this preference, their body mass and fat reserves increased, even while total caloric intake remained virtually unchanged. Since wheat and rice produced comparable outcomes, this ruled out any effect specific to the properties of a single grain.
Analysis pinpointed several core physiological shifts: a decrease in energy expenditure, elevated levels of fatty acids in the bloodstream, a reduction in essential amino acid content, and the activation of pathways for fat synthesis and transport within the liver.
“These findings suggest that weight gain is linked to metabolic alterations caused by a preference for carbohydrates, rather than specific attributes of wheat alone,” explained Shigenobu Matsumura.
Importantly, once the carbohydrate-rich flour was withdrawn from the diet, both body weight and metabolic markers rapidly returned to baseline levels.
The authors emphasize that these results cannot be directly extrapolated to human physiology. Nevertheless, the research demonstrates that the composition of one’s diet, more than just its calories, influences energy utilization. A sustained diet dominated by refined carbohydrates—such as bread, flour products, rice, and pasta—has the potential to modify metabolic “efficiency”—the amount of energy an organism naturally expends at rest and during activity.
The analysis uncovered the key physiological changes. The subsequent phase involves verifying these patterns in human subjects. The scientists plan to assess whether these observed effects persist within real-world eating habits, investigate the role of whole grain products and dietary fiber, examine how the impact of carbohydrates interacts with proteins and fats, and explore the significance of meal timing and pattern.
Professor Matsumura further commented:
“In the future, we hope this will provide a scientific foundation for balancing ‘palatability’ against ‘health’ in nutritional guidelines.”
About the Author
